Today, I drove to work. After work, I left and stopped at my neighborhood gas station. When I went out to start my car and head home, it did not start. No turning over, just a click. The battery seems to be in fine shape. Even tried jumping it.

My first instinct is a new starter? As far as I know it is original or old. Is there anything else I should check for? The indicator lights and everything come on just as they should. Thanks for the help!

 

does sound like a starter.
"good shape"? so, battery is still a rectangular box? you can't look at battery and judge how good is it. lights inside mean nothing too. and it all depends, HOW you jumped it.
1st thing 1st - remove and clean cable terminals and battery poles.
when jumping, make sure you have KNOWN GOOD JUMPER CABLES, not cheap Walmart rusted ones. and jump off running car battery, not just a battery.